Mankind Pharma vs. Glaxo
January 13th, 2012Recently, I went to meet a doctor for a health condition. The doctor suspected some infection and prescribed anti-biotics. Moreover, he wanted me to support Glaxo over Mankind Pharma. Now in case you are wondering. The doctor figured I am a rich guy and so I, should support big drug companies which spend millions of dollars in R and D and take doctors to exotic locations for their paid vacations over drug companies who copy the medicine formulas after the patent expiry. Yes, the doctor prescribed Augmentin 625, the chemical name of which is Amoxycillin-Clavulanic Acid. Each tablet costs about 40 Rs. I was asked to take a course of 10. On the other hand, there is a generic pharma company called Mankind Pharma which manufactures the same drug and calls it Ramaswamy aka MOXIKIND-CV 625 instead of Kuppuswamy aka Augmentin, and interestingly offers the tablet for 15 Rs. It is not as if Moxikind is manufactured by Selvasingh annachi kadai in Medavakkam. Mankind is also a recognized pharma company.
I buy the medicines and came home happy, only to find Thangamani fuming.
She thinks the doc took me for a ride by prescribing a more expensive brand when there are cheaper but as effective options available. Thangamani and her ‘pal’ doctor colleagues always prescribe Ramaswamy (the Mankind pharma brand) and apparently it’s as effective and evidently costs 25 Rs. less per tablet.
Interestingly for the other anti-biotic, the doc prescribes the generic ‘metrodinazole’ when the popular brand is Flagyl. Why? This one costs 7 Rs. for 9 tablets. No wonder he did not care what I bought, my wife says.
How do I know Augmentin is a brand name for Amoxycillin-Clavulanic Acid tablets and the same thing can also be called Ramaswamy by Mankind Pharma and it would cost less?
On hearing this, my mom started how I always paid more to fruit vendors, vegetable vendors, auto drivers, etc. - Somehow they all figured I am one sucker and this doctor is the latest is mom’s theory.
My friends told me I would’ve mentioned something which made the doc feel ‘Oh here’s one more jobless IT guy who had searched endlessly on the net for the symptoms and conditions’ and so charged a 100 bucks more for consultation and a few more on medicines.
All said and done, I have recovered from my condition, and I am happy that I contribute my bit to the economy, keep the medical fraternity in good humour, and support big pharma. More paid vacations to the doctors!
