Vatsan has written about THAMBRAAS and reservation issue.
I know i have 144ed myself from this topic but felt like writing some parts which i have not written before in my blog. So i thought let me break my own 144 and post it here for once.
I personally think reservation is the most destructive thing that could’ve happened to the Contemporary Indian society.
Those who have the time and effort should go and find out the number of backward castes in the 40-50s and now. They would realise that the number of communities in the backward category has actually swelled over the years.
Those in the forward community has successfully been able to get declared as backward and those in the backward has moved to Most Backward.
Vazhga reservation!!
But I hate reservation for an entirely different reason. Assume you have two children, say identical twins for convenience sake, tell X that he is strong and so can run for 10 minutes, tell the other Y that since he is weak its enough he runs for only 5 minutes. Chances are, in the course of time X will be really strong and can endure enough and Y will be relatively weaker.
So psychologically, by expecting lesser performance from backward communities, we are crippling them in their psyche. Its just another way of saying ‘you are inferior’.
The best way to bring equality is by affirming in their minds that all are capable and equal. So long as this belief is not instilled, reservation policy will defeat the very purpose of its creation. What people from backward classes and backward areas need is some support in terms of information, guidance not some quota of seats. All backward community guys would do well to realise about something called 4 minute mile barrier. Its toughest when you are doing something for the first time among your community circles. Like say getting into IIT in merit.
After that it just becomes a routine.
Vatsan has mentioned “he knows he cant compete against the superior intelligence of the Brahmin and the Forward communities”
This is classic case of conditioning.
What about children where one of the parent is a brahmin and the other non-brahmin? Half-intelligent and half-dumb is it?
For starters, the word intelligence will connote a wider meaning than getting good grades by mugging. There is a lot of research going on in the areas of cognitive psychology. Those who have time can search for one Howard Gardner and his concept of Multiple Intelligence.
According to this concept, Intelligence can be classified into
Visual/Spatial Intelligence
Verbal/Linguistic Intelligence
Logical/Mathematical Intelligence
Bodily/Kinesthetic Intelligence
Musical/Rhythmic Intelligence
Interpersonal Intelligence
Intrapersonal Intelligence
Going by this theory, if Ramanujamwas a genius, so was Mahatma Gandhi or Ilayaraja or Michael Jordan.
If there is one aspect where forward community guys score, it’s in the network in the collective information they have. For eg. I never knew about one NID when I was in twelfth. But my brahmin friend did. This is because his someone’s someone’s someone had done a course there. Whereas my someone’s someone’s someone’s was invariably running a jewellery shop in madurai and thought that was the coolest thing on earth. This can be easily traced to one’s ancestors having an advantage in terms of education.
Now what with google, even some idiot in chennai (me) can talk about Howard Gardner. So that gap is fast closing down.
Regarding reservations for Brahmins…When I am dead against the concept of reservation, the question of reservation for Brahmins do not arise.
More than anything if this THAMBRAAS will put up a united face and put an end to all the brahmin bashing happening in all the media, I will be very happy. But then as monu has rightly pointed out, there is just too much gossiping and politiking among the brahmin community, not to mention elitism. Anyway its their business and let them do in the manner they deem fit.