Comments on: Yet another post on the reservation issue http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/ Rombo nallavan Fri, 18 May 2012 08:32:06 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.2.1 By: Prabu Karthik http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4074 Prabu Karthik Sun, 28 May 2006 03:11:00 +0000 http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4074 priyums nee dhaan ennoda manasaatchi :D priyums nee dhaan ennoda manasaatchi :D

]]> By: priyums http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4073 priyums Fri, 26 May 2006 01:29:00 +0000 http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4073 I also studied in BITS. After a few years you will figure if you are from BITS, IIT or any engineering college you get the same position depending on your capabilities. BITS, IITS , all hi fi schools in the cities that claim their x% of their students are going to BITS and IIT's dont take kids that cannot afford that type of education. They also have only 'business' in mind. And also Just because your 12th exam percentage went low you cannot be judged to be having less IQ. COnsidering financial factors and economic factors..like Ravi said we need to think and give some sort of help to kids who want to study and are deprived of resources. The help could also be provided to start some business..Who says getting a degree is the only option. Did Birla study in a school like BITS Pilani?? But the very question is :is changing the reservation quota going to make any difference to the poor..may be 5% of the cases..Like Karthik said it is all driven by people who have say and interest in their own well being..not of the country. I also studied in BITS. After a few years you will figure if you are from BITS, IIT or any engineering college you get the same position depending on your capabilities. BITS, IITS , all hi fi schools in the cities that claim their x% of their students are going to BITS and IIT’s dont take kids that cannot afford that type of education. They also have only ‘business’ in mind. And also Just because your 12th exam percentage went low you cannot be judged to be having less IQ. COnsidering financial factors and economic factors..like Ravi said we need to think and give some sort of help to kids who want to study and are deprived of resources. The help could also be provided to start some business..Who says getting a degree is the only option. Did Birla study in a school like BITS Pilani?? But the very question is :is changing the reservation quota going to make any difference to the poor..may be 5% of the cases..Like Karthik said it is all driven by people who have say and interest in their own well being..not of the country.

]]> By: Prabu Karthik http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4072 Prabu Karthik Thu, 25 May 2006 17:14:00 +0000 http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4072 sridhar, casteist freaks are there in all communities... gowri, its pretty complex, and so long as we dont recognise the complexity and give out doles for votes nothing is gonna happen.. i would like to see the day when BC students say they dont need reservation...and slo when the so called well educated communities realise that some sections of the society may not be as well endowed as they are... sridhar,

casteist freaks are there in all communities…

gowri,
its pretty complex, and so long as we dont recognise the complexity and give out doles for votes nothing is gonna happen..
i would like to see the day when BC students say they dont need reservation…and slo when the so called well educated communities realise that some sections of the society may not be as well endowed as they are…

]]> By: Gowri Sankar http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4071 Gowri Sankar Thu, 25 May 2006 02:27:00 +0000 http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4071 PK. Good write up. Reservations should be only on economic status of the students. There are many many students in our country who are below the economic line (or) poverty line - whatever line is... Politicians are doing what they do best... gain all politicial points in the battleground... do/use whatever it takes... Inspite of all the resources we have(natural/human/technology), our politicians will ensure that we will always be a developing country... Instead of reserving the seats for communities in education why not the government give scholarships.. Out of the 100 seats, 50% of the seats are offered under scholarship for backward communities.. ? Is'nt this a good idea? PK. Good write up. Reservations should be only on economic status of the students. There are many many students in our country who are below the economic line (or) poverty line - whatever line is…

Politicians are doing what they do best… gain all politicial points in the battleground… do/use whatever it takes…

Inspite of all the resources we have(natural/human/technology), our politicians will ensure that we will always be a developing country…

Instead of reserving the seats for communities in education why not the government give scholarships.. Out of the 100 seats, 50% of the seats are offered under scholarship for backward communities.. ? Is’nt this a good idea?

]]> By: Sridhar http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4070 Sridhar Thu, 25 May 2006 02:18:00 +0000 http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4070 I long for the day when there are so many intercaste marriages that caste becomes irrelevant. Many people who stringently call for "merrit" in education are extremely casteist when it comes to their personal life. Just check any matrimonial website,highly educated and so called broad minded sections of society advertising for a spouse belonging to this "subcaste" of this "caste". I sense some hypocrisy in all this guys. The only solution is to completely eradicate the caste system from our personal and professional lives. I long for the day when there are so many intercaste marriages that caste becomes irrelevant. Many people who stringently call for “merrit” in education are extremely casteist when it comes to their personal life. Just check any matrimonial website,highly educated and so called broad minded sections of society advertising for a spouse belonging to this “subcaste” of this “caste”. I sense some hypocrisy in all this guys. The only solution is to completely eradicate the caste system from our personal and professional lives.

]]> By: Prabu Karthik http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4069 Prabu Karthik Thu, 25 May 2006 01:51:00 +0000 http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4069 dinesh, Those kids need more mentoring and guidance and financial help for their studies and less quotas. if at all we r going to have ths quotas then the backward rurals areas factor and their economic status shud also definitely taken into account so that kids like marimuthu benefit... i am saying we as a society have ignored that marimuthu and people like him. i am saying those who shout now r doing more out of their vested interest than any national interest or any consciouness of or merit, fairplay and social justice.. where were they when the govt introduced Payment seats in Engg. colleges? Those who r well off and living in urban areas and who actively seek reservation r the worst... those r belong to OC communities and who cud not care less abt anything but only abt their welfare comes next. i dont find fault with them but then nothing exemplary either... the real disprivileged people are those whose voices r never heard... I know one MBC student, he did his schooling in a govt school near aruppukottai which i heard was built by kamarajar, a topper there, he later got into Anna University Textile engineering, he was a topper there too...he is in the US now. I somehow think this person's achievement is better than those who r city bred and use all the facilities that only a city can offer and then claim that they got everything thru merit blah blah... indha madhiri neraya per irukaanga... andha payyan padikalena edhavadhu maligai kadaila pottalam poda poiruppan... nalla padikkara fwd community payyanuku seat kedaikalena its not fair, i definitely agree. but then that person can atleast settle for a lesser college. but what r we going to do with the marimuthus is my questions...have we as a society and our govts been fair to them? dinesh,

Those kids need more mentoring and guidance and financial help for their studies and less quotas.

if at all we r going to have ths quotas then the backward rurals areas factor and their economic status shud also definitely taken into account so that kids like marimuthu benefit…

i am saying we as a society have ignored that marimuthu and people like him.

i am saying those who shout now r doing more out of their vested interest than any national interest or any consciouness of or merit, fairplay and social justice..

where were they when the govt introduced Payment seats in Engg. colleges?

Those who r well off and living in urban areas and who actively seek reservation r the worst…

those r belong to OC communities and who cud not care less abt anything but only abt their welfare comes next. i dont find fault with them but then nothing exemplary either…

the real disprivileged people are those whose voices r never heard…

I know one MBC student, he did his schooling in a govt school near aruppukottai which i heard was built by kamarajar, a topper there, he later got into Anna University Textile engineering, he was a topper there too…he is in the US now.

I somehow think this person’s achievement is better than those who r city bred and use all the facilities that only a city can offer and then claim that they got everything thru merit blah blah…

indha madhiri neraya per irukaanga…

andha payyan padikalena edhavadhu maligai kadaila pottalam poda poiruppan…

nalla padikkara fwd community payyanuku seat kedaikalena its not fair, i definitely agree. but then that person can atleast settle for a lesser college.

but what r we going to do with the marimuthus is my questions…have we as a society and our govts been fair to them?

]]> By: Risha http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4068 Risha Thu, 25 May 2006 01:30:00 +0000 http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4068 A well-thought post. I cannot draw upon what stand I should take.But like you rightly put there is always the lot who are cursed with ignorance,unaware of the fact that colleges even existed, who need a dose of cure. Who would formulate the anti-dote , the question remains... A well-thought post.
I cannot draw upon what stand I should take.But like you rightly put there is always the lot who are cursed with ignorance,unaware of the fact that colleges even existed, who need a dose of cure.
Who would formulate the anti-dote , the question remains…

]]> By: Prabu Karthik http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4067 Prabu Karthik Thu, 25 May 2006 01:25:00 +0000 http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4067 ganesh, i am not sayng that is fair...but as a society we have ignored a sizeable section of the society's progress. how fair it is if we r only concerned abt the city bred and well read students... to my knowledge the only political leader who built primary schools (as u rightly said)in all corners of the state without bothering abt votes is kamarajar... ganesh,

i am not sayng that is fair…but as a society we have ignored a sizeable section of the society’s progress.

how fair it is if we r only concerned abt the city bred and well read students…

to my knowledge the only political leader who built primary schools (as u rightly said)in all corners of the state without bothering abt votes is kamarajar…

]]> By: Prabu Karthik http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4066 Prabu Karthik Thu, 25 May 2006 01:21:00 +0000 http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4066 monu, i can relate to yr plight. but my point is there r still some who cannot even dream of getting a good education. they r very much the citizens of this country.. what r we going to do with them? what social justice is that if we leave those sections completley out of the picture... monu,
i can relate to yr plight.
but my point is there r still some who cannot even dream of getting a good education. they r very much the citizens of this country..

what r we going to do with them? what social justice is that if we leave those sections completley out of the picture…

]]> By: dinesh http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4065 dinesh Thu, 25 May 2006 01:19:00 +0000 http://expertdabbler.com/2006/05/24/yet-another-post-on-the-reservation-issue/#comment-4065 Nice write up.. Oru doubt ? When you talk about marimuthu..are you saying that the reservation system fails to impact him or you're just suggestinng that the govenment's energy should rather be spent on making him aware of what his opportunities are ? btw, I wrote a big-ass comment, which was lost by this stupid "page not displayed"..No energy to re-type it. Free vittutten ! :) Nice write up..

Oru doubt ? When you talk about marimuthu..are you saying that the reservation system fails to impact him or you’re just suggestinng that the govenment’s energy should rather be spent on making him aware of what his opportunities are ?

btw, I wrote a big-ass comment, which was lost by this stupid “page not displayed”..No energy to re-type it. Free vittutten ! :)

]]>