The economics of chennai autos - 2
Here is what I have in terms of suggestions and solutions. Of course all or any of this can be dabated, discussed and ridiculed.
I think no political or legal measures will make the life better for the common man. Such has been the law enforcement –criminal-political nexus that I’ve lost all hope on these types. I feel, things should work on a much smaller scale. Afterall individual honesty should be much easier than corporate honesty. But unfortunately in a country like India where citizens have a huge gap between what they preach and and what they practice, the market is the only way effective judge. The only way to hit ruthlessly and effectively is through economic measures.
So here we go.
Make a law which empowers the government to award running this whole auto rickshaw transport business to some corporates. The government should only try to administer at a very high level by fixing minimum, maximum rates, specifying training etc( yes training, I’ll come to it later). The government can collect license fees too. I’m not an MBA but entry by corporates who may have the funding to operate on a mega scale may bring the prices down and make it affordable for the common man.
But how about our labour force? After all auto drivers are not MBAs from IIMs but more similar to workers who sweat it out. How will they behave?
Well that’s precisely one of the reasons why I advocate corporates running this whole auto business.
I don’t know if it’s a desi thing. But Indian labour can function very well within a given set of rules, a hierarch to supervise, a performance based incentive system and a stable organisational structure. They basically want someone to take care of them. But our labour is pathetic when it comes to managing things on their own without any supervision.
For example, I think the auto drivers would be happy to work for a base salary, with performance bonus on every extra mile driven above the target or revenue generated. But leave it to them to govern themselves and all hell breaks lose. They’d rather sit with an old Dhinathanthi and tea glass in each hands whilst looking to make enough money for the day in a single savari. The bottomline, enough skill but lack of self-discipline.
The Businessworld dated Aug 21 has an interesting article on the changing face of the blue collar workers in our country. The article talks about ITI graduates, who toil for 12-16 hours, who have their own pack of credit cards and some even own cars as well. That was real gladdening news but it also pointed out another aspect - how many would’ve done as much or even half as much if they were running their own Small scale units? Not many, in my opinion.
In India, whenever the services sector has let in the corporates and whenever the government stayed away from day to day administrations, the system has worked very well indeed for the customer.
From the government front they should provide directions like what sort of training the driver should need to take and setup certifying exams as applicable for auto drivers. This may sound funny, but I think clean habits(at least on duty), courtesy, and knowledge of the city are mandatory for an auto driver. I’ve faced situations where the auto driver’s knowledge of the city was pathetic. One guy asked me once ”Anna arivalayama, adhu enga irukku?” The assumption right now, that auto drivers know the city well is just that, our assumption.
To summarise, follow the lessons learnt in all other areas and open this out to some corporate who has deep pockets. Let the business fuel its autos with petrol,diesel,LPG, water or whatever.
The corporate may soon be filthy rich at the expense of auto drivers, but I don’t see a way out for the common man.
September 19th, 2006 at 11:17 pm
Kalasita po.. same/similar kind of training should be given for our “so called” politicians..
September 20th, 2006 at 6:02 am
Agreed. Corporates running auto-rickshaws is a good idea. The problem however is that I don’t see it happening. Unfortunately, the most important factors that determine whether something like this can happen is the resistance to change (even good changes) from the auto-drivers, thevai illaadha criticism and consequently the vote bank hit that the government would take as a result. The DMK government would dare not think of doing such a thing given their tendencies in the past to keep their vote-bank healthy, inspite of very few such revolutions and their way of retaining/capturng power through conservative methods. The ADMK is beter equipped to bring about such a transfromation, but it’s not like they’re not concerned about the vote bank hit that this move promises to bring about.
But nice post ! I enjoyed it. I like it that you write such articles with the common man’s interests in mind.
September 20th, 2006 at 3:46 pm
PK,
My reply in my blog
Sorry for using your blog for advertising
September 20th, 2006 at 11:11 pm
ha ha ha .. Interesting Idea. Being from IIM doesn’t make us the only Hope for innovation.
This is a nice idea.. However, I can go on to associate a few Pros and Cons to the ideas … and Punctuate it with “it depends” clause.
It still is nice in terms of finding a suitable environment which lets it survive and fit into a developed city we see in the future.
Unless, the project suits our future needs .. it would remain an utopian thought.
***claps**
September 21st, 2006 at 5:38 am
Think of auto driver as the common man!
September 21st, 2006 at 10:40 am
gopi
danks dude:)
nalla idea daan, but adha legislature a corporation a pana mudiyadhey?
September 21st, 2006 at 10:42 am
dinesh,
well thats a different ball game if u ask me:)
actually its not a difficult proposition if u ask me,
well Sun TV groupa la irundhu ipdi oru proposal pochu na udaney ok aydum
September 21st, 2006 at 10:43 am
dany,
i read yr blog y’day. cud not comment. i will come to yr blog today:)
September 21st, 2006 at 10:53 am
jinguchakka,
Auto driver will be considerd as a common ma only when they pay as dearly as we do to auto drivers:)
September 21st, 2006 at 12:00 pm
Nice writeup PK, even the part 1:)
Its been years i have travel in Autos.